Anne-Marie Watson, Andrew Paul McSkimming, Ross Gordon Allen and Patricia Ann Allen ENV-2018-CHC-226 - Anne-Marie Watson, Andrew Paul McSkimming, Ross Gordon Allen and Patricia Ann Allen Anne-Marie Watson, Andrew Paul McSkimming, Ross Gordon Allen and Patricia Ann Allen (15) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Rural Residential Zoning] 30 August 2022 |
Rural Residential zones
|
Otago Regional Council
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Anthony Reid and Hilary Evans ENV-2018-CHC-261 - Anthony Reid and Hilary Evans Anthony Reid and Hilary Evans (179, 365) Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 October 2022 | Natural hazards, Urban land supply | Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Aurora Energy Limited ENV-2018-CHC-277 - Aurora Energy Limited Consent Memorandum Aurora Energy Limited (245) 2 October 2019 Memorandum of Counsel regarding Variation 1 17 December 2019 Aurora Energy Limited (237) - Memorandum of Counsel to withdraw partial of appeal [Network utilities] 16 January 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Aurora consent memo 14 May 2020 Aurora Energy Limited (245) Consent order issued by Environment Court 10 June 2020 [Earthworks rule] Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Residential Strategic Bundle 4 December 2020 Consent Order - Residential Strategic Bundle 18 December 2020 Aurora Energy Limited (240, 243) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Network utilities, Scheduled Trees] 3 December 2021 Aurora Energy Limited (214, 217, 218, 220, 221, 222, 223, 225, 226, 227, 231, 234, 239, 247, 248, 249, 372, 395, 396, 397, 398, 399, 402, 244) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] Aurora Energy Limited (228) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 6 June 2023 | Earthworks (resolved), Natural environment, Network utilities, Plan overview and structure, Public health and safety, Scheduled trees | BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Director General of Conservation Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Horticulture New Zealand Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Liquigas Limited - withdrawn Radio New Zealand Limited Royal Forest and Bird Spark New Zealand Trading Limited, Chorus New Zealand Limited and Vodafone New Zealand Limited Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu Transpower New Zealand Limited University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
BA Building Limited ENV-2018-CHC-259 - BA Building Limited BA Building Limited (137) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Residential Zoning - Site Specific Bundle] 12 August 2022 |
Urban Land Supply
| Jennifer Diane Stadnyk (on behalf of Soper Road Residents) Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Bennett - Chelivode Street ENV-2018-CHC-227 - Bennett - Chelivode Street Bennett - Chelivode Street (48) Consent order issued by Environment Court 29 March 2023 |
Urban land supply
| Anthony Haereroa Parata Blueskin Bay Watch Society Incorporated Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Bennett - Doctors Point ENV-2018-CHC-228 - Bennett - Doctors Point Bennett - Doctors Point (50, 51, 52) Consent order issued by Environment Court 29 March 2023 |
Natural environment, Urban land supply
| Anthony Haereroa Parata Blueskin Bay Watch Society Incorporated Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Ben Ponne ENV-2018-CHC-260 - Ben Ponne Memorandum of Counsel withdrawing specific relief point 12 February 2019 Ben Ponne (151) - Consent Memorandum lodged with Environment Court for approval 10 June 2021 Ben Ponne (151) Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 August 2021 |
Rural residential zones
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Blue Grass Limited and Others ENV-2018-CHC-293 - Blue Grass Limited and Others Blue Grass Limited and Others partial withdrawal 20 December 2019 Blue Grass Limited and Others (285) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Manawhenua] 16 September 2020 Blue Grass Limited and Others - Notice of amendment of relief sought 16 December 2022 Blue Grass Limited and Others - Notice of withdrawal of Craig Horne 17 January 2023 Blue Grass Limited and Others (251, 252, 253, 254, 278, 280, 283, part 266) - Consent order issued by the Environment Court 3 April 2025 Blue Grass Limited and Others - Notice of withdrawal of Highland Property Enterprises Limited as agents for Saddle Hill Estates Limited (part 266) 19 September 2025 | Manawhenua, Natural environment, Natural hazards, Rural residential zones, Urban land supply | David Stewart and Maria Stewart-Haverkort Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Otago Regional Council Highland Property Enterprises Limited | Appeal Resolved |
Blueskin Bay Holdings Limited ENV-2018-CHC-279 - Blueskin Bay Holdings Limited Blueskin Bay Holdings Limited (150) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Rural Residential Zoning] 23 November 2022 |
Rural residential zones
|
Otago Regional Council
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Blueskin Projects Limited and Others ENV-2018-CHC-276 - Blueskin Projects Limited and Others General Residential 2 2GP Map (West)
Inner City Res A
Inner City Res B Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (139) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Residential zoning] 3 September 2019 Blueskin Projects Limited and Others - Notice of Refined /narrowed relief of appeal point 149 3 September 2019 Minute of Environment Court regarding Rural and Rural Residential consent memo 19 May 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle 30 April 2021 ENV-2018-CHC-276 - Consent Memorandum 22 April 2021 Blueskin Projects and Others (142) Consent order issued by Environment Court 5 May 2021 [Residential Zoning Site Specific] Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (153,155,156,160,163,164,166,168,170) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 August 2021 [Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle] Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (149) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 20 September 2021 [Earthworks and Major Hazard Facilities Bundle] Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (173) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Tree Rules] 28 February 2022 Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (381) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Natural Hazards] 9 March 2022 Blueskin Projects Limited and Others (174) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 17 May 2022 [Transportation] |
Natural hazards, Residential zones, Rural zones, Scheduled trees, Transportation
| Construction Industry and Developers Association Gladstone Family Trust Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Otago Regional Council - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others ENV-2018-CHC-291 - BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Consent Memorandum for BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others (349) 15 October 2019 Memorandum from DCC regarding explanation of BP Oil's appeal points 356 and 359 Minute of Environment Court in response to DCC's explanation of BP Oil's appeal points 356 and 359 Minute of Environment Court regarding BP Oil's consent memo 19 May 2020 BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (374) 16 November 2020 BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others (352, 353) Consent order issued by Environment Court 20 September 2021 BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others (181, 346, 349, 351, 354, 355, 356, 374) Consent order issued by Environment Court 20 September 2021 [Earthworks and Major Hazard Facilities Bundle] BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others (358) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 6 June 2023 BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others (347, 348, 350) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Earthworks, Industrial zones, Natural environment, Network utilities, Plan overview and structure, Public health and safety, Service stations (cross plan hearing topic)
| Aurora Energy Limited Bindon Holdings Limited Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Horticulture New Zealand Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou LPG Association Liquigas Limited Oceana Gold Port Otago Limited Royal Forest and Bird Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu Transpower New Zealand Limited University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeals Resolved
|
Bruce Norrish ENV-2018-CHC-248 - Bruce Norrish Bruce Norrish - Decision of the Environment Court [Natural environment] 6 June 2023 |
Natural environment
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Bruce Wayne Taylor and the Estate of Lawrence Taylor ENV-2018-CHC-244 - Bruce Wayne Taylor and the Estate of Lawrence Taylor Minute of Environment Court regarding Rural and Rural Residential consent memo 19 May 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle 30 April 2021 Bruce Wayne Taylor and the Estate of Lawrence Taylor (10) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 August 2021 [Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle] PCT (75, 82, part 70, 341) and Bruce Wayne Taylor (13) - Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court Landscape Bundle 17 November 2021 PCT (75, 82, part 70, 341) and Bruce Wayne Taylor (13) Consent order issued by Environment Court 24 November 2021 |
Natural environment, Rural zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Careys Bay Association Incorporated ENV-2018-CHC-223 - Careys Bay Association Incorporated Careys Bay Association Incorporated & Port Otago Limited (23, 25, 27, 34, 35) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Port Bundle] 04 August 2022 |
Port zone
|
Port Otago Limited
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Cavendish Chambers Limited ENV-2018-CHC-231 - Cavendish Chambers Limited Memorandum of Counsel 23 April 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Chorus New Zealand Limited, Spark New Zealand Trading Limited and Vodafone New Zealand Limited ENV-2018-CHC-230 - Chorus New Zealand Limited, Spark New Zealand Trading Limited and Vodafone New Zealand Limited Chorus New Zealand Limited, Spark New Zealand Trading Limited and Vodafone New Zealand Limited notice of partial appeal (383) 19 November 2020 Chorus New Zealand Limited, Spark New Zealand Trading Limited and Vodafone New Zealand Limited (39, 44) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] |
Network utilities
| Aurora Energy Limited BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others - Notice of BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others partial withdrawal as s274 9 September 2020
Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Kiwi Rail Holdings Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
Daisy Link Garden Centres Limited ENV-2018-CHC-266 - Daisy Link Garden Centres Limited Daisy Link Garden Centres Limited (188) Consent Order issued by Environment Court 18 March 2022 |
Urban land supply
| Alison Jane Rutherford Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Director General of Conservation ENV-2018-CHC-243 - Director General of Conservation Director General of Conservation notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (60) 23 October 2020 Director General of Conservation (83, 85, 87) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Biodiversity and Rail Bundle] 7 October 2022 |
Natural environment
| Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Royal Forest and Bird The Preservation Coalition Trust Transpower New Zealand Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Douglas Wayne Hall ENV-2018-CHC-232 - Douglas Wayne Hall Douglas Wayne Hall - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 April 2022 [Scheduled trees] Douglas Wayne Hall - Consent order issued by Environment Cour 16 June 2022 [Residential Zoning -NEV] |
Scheduled trees, Urban land supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Dunedin International Airport Limited ENV-2018-CHC-274 - Dunedin International Airport Limited Dunedin International Airport Limited (199, 200, 201, 202) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 7 October 2022 |
Commercial advertising decision report, Major facilities (without Port and Mercy Hospital)
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated ENV-2018-CHC-254 - Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated - Notice of partial withdrawal (186, 193, 207) 29 July 2019 Minute from Environment Court regarding Rural and Rural Residential consent memo 19 May 2020 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated - Notice of partial withdrawal (195, 197) 29 June 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle 30 April 2021 Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (345) 8 June 2021 Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated (189) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 August 2021 [Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle] Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated (204) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated (165) - Consent order issued by Environment Court [Rural] 7 July 2022 Federated Farmers of New Zealand (175, 184) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Biodiversity and Rail Bundle] 7 October 2022 Federated Farmers of New Zealand (345) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Earthworks, Natural environment, Network utilities, Plan overview and structure, Public health and safety, Rural zones
| Aurora Energy Limited BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Dunedin Rural Development Incorporated Horticulture New Zealand Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Liquigas Limited Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Royal Forest and Bird Transpower New Zealand Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Fonterra Limited ENV-2018-CHC-251 - Fonterra Limited Fonterra Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (162) 5 August 2019 Fonterra Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (167) 1 April 2022 [Transportation] Fonterra Limited (136, 158) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 5 September 2022 [Mosgiel noise control area] Fonterra Limited (172) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Public health and safety, Rural zones, Transportation
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Gary Pollock - withdrawn Jane McLeod Liquigas Limited Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Port Otago Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Foodstuffs South Island Properties Limited ENV-2018-CHC-238 - Foodstuffs South Island Properties Limited Memorandum of Counsel to Environment Court CMU Campus Bundle 23 April 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Liquigas Limited - withdrawn - Liquigas Limited notice of withdrawal as s274 party
Woolworths New Zealand Limited | |
Gladstone Family Trust ENV-2018-CHC-262 - Gladstone Family Trust Gladstone Family Trust (121) Consent order issued by Environment Court 03 August 2022 |
Urban Land Supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Grandview 2011 Limited ENV-2018-CHC-225 - Grandview 2011 Limited Grandview 2011 Limited (21, 377, 378) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 29 March 2022 [Rural residential zones] |
Rural residential zones
| Candler Sheffield Rogers Christine Keller and Fieke Neuman Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Gregory Paul Ward ENV-2018-CHC-284 - Gregory Paul Ward ENV-2018-CHC-284 - Consent memorandum 19 October 2020 Consent Order for Gregory Paul Ward (66) Residential Zoning Site Specific bundle 4 may 2021 |
Urban land supply
| Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated - Withdrawn - Notice of Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated withdrawing s274 interest
Otago Regional Council - Withdrawn - Notice of Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated withdrawing s274 interest
RPR Properties Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Harvey Norman Property Limited ENV-2018-CHC-235 - Harvey Norman Property Limited Harvey Norman Property Limited (33) Consent Order issued by Environment Court 21 September 2022 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| Lion NZ Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Heart of Dunedin Incorporated ENV-2018-CHC-239 - Heart of Dunedin Incorporated Consent Memorandum Heart of Dunedin Incorporated Consent order for Heart of Dunedin Incorporated 26 May 2020 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
|
Bindon Holdings Limited - withdrawn
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Hilary Jane Calvert ENV-2018-CHC-233 - Hilary Jane Calvert and Craig Horne Surveyors Limited Craig Horne Surveyors Limited - Notice of withdrawal as appellant 8 April 2022 Hilary Jane Calvert (38) Consent Order issued by Environment Court [Residential] 17 August 2022 |
Residential zones
| Hilary Hutton University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
James Lin Limited ENV-2018-CHC-263 - James Lin Limited James Lin Limited (116, 117) Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 October 2022 |
Urban land supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Jean Grace ENV-2018-CHC-215 - Jean Grace Jean Grace (9) - Consent Memorandum lodged with the Environment Court for approval 7 October 2021 Jean Grace (9) - Consent Order issued by the Environment Court 11 November 2021 |
Urban land supply
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
John Stewart Findlater ENV-2018-CHC-220 - John Stewart Findlater John Stewart Findlater (16) - Consent Memorandum lodged with the Environment Court for approval 30 April 2021 John Stewart Findlater (16, 357) Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 August 2021 |
Rural residential zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Kaan's Properties 2017 Limited ENV-2018-CHC-286 - Kaan's Properties 2017 Limited Memorandum of Counsel of the Environment Court 23 April 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| Liquigas Limited Otago Regional Council University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou ENV-2018-CHC-240 - Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou - amended 1 March 2019 s274 withdrawal from some appeal topics - Kati Huirapa Runaka ki Puketeraki Te Runanga o Otakou 22.3.19 Notice of Kati Huirapa Runaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Runanga o Otakou withdrawing s274 interest 18 June 2020 Notice of Kati Huirapa Runaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Runanga o Otakou partial withdrawal of appeal 13 October 2020 Memorandum of Counsel (Manawhenua Bundle) Consent order - Runaka 16 March 2021 Kati Huirapa Runaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Runanga o Otakou - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (375) 22 March 2022 |
Manawhenua, Quarries and mining activities (cross plan hearing topic), Rural zones
| Blackhead Quarries Limited Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Heritage New Zealand - withdrawn Oceana Gold Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Saddle Views Estate Limited Tussock Top Farm Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated ENV-2018-CHC-218 - Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated Minute of Environment Court 14 May 2020 Memorandum of Counsel regarding Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural and RPR Properties 30 June 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Dalziel Road 14 July 2020 Keep Halfway Bush Semi-Rural Incorporated (8) Consent Order issued by Environment Court 6 August 2021 |
Urban land supply
| Christopher James and Rebecca Jean Climie Fahey David John Griffiths and Megan Elizabeth Macaulay DN Innovations Limited Doreen Mary and Steven La Mar Sharp Gregory Paul Ward James Edgeworth and Andrea Kate Ussher James Russell and Joanne Mary Hawker Justin Lindsay and Vanessa Lauren Geddes Peter Francis and Rachel Anne Mortimer RPR Properties Limited Robert Ross and Gaynor Anne McTaggart Steven Douglas and Sonia Michelle MacPherson |
Appeal Resolved
|
KiwiRail Holdings Limited ENV-2018-CHC-252 - KiwiRail Holdings Limited Memorandum of Counsel to Environment Court 4 December 2020 – Residential Strategic Bundle Consent order - Residential Strategic Bundle 18 December 2020 KiwiRail Holdings Limited (229, 230, 232, 233, 400, 401) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Biodiversity and Rail Bundle] 7 October 2022 |
Natural environment, Transportation
| Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Otago Regional Council Royal Forest and Bird Transpower New Zealand Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Liquigas Limited ENV-2018-CHC-229 - Liquigas Limited Liquigas Limited - Memo of partial withdrawal of appeal (47, 56, 57, 92, 95) 9 July 2019 Liquigas Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (105, 113, 115) 31 July 2020 Liquigas Limited - Consent order issued by Environment Court (40, 58, 59, 62, 64, 69, 74, 76, 81, 84, 88, 89, 100, 102, 108, 110, 120, 123, 128, 129, 132, 133) 20 September 2021 [Earthworks and Major Hazard Facilities Bundle] Liquigas Limited (80) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Industrial zones, Network utilities, Plan overview and structure, Public health and safety
| Aurora Energy Limited BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) Horticulture New Zealand Minister of Defence Oceana Gold Transpower New Zealand Limited University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
LPG Association of New Zealand ENV-2018-CHC-289 - LPG Association of New Zealand LPG Association of New Zealand (178) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Public health and safety
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Horticulture New Zealand Liquigas Limited Otago Regional Council Transpower New Zealand Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Michael Ovens ENV-2018-CHC-292 - Michael Ovens Memorandum of partial withdrawal of appeal 23 April 2020 Memorandum for change of service Memorandum of partial withdrawal of appeal (367) 12 October 2020 Michael Ovens (73, 367, 380) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Rural Res Zoning] 17 August 2022 |
Natural environment, Urban land supply
|
Otago Regional Council
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Nichols Property Group Limited, Home Centre Properties Limited and London Realty Limited ENV-2018-CHC-217 - Nichols Property Group Limited, Home Centre Properties Limited and London Realty Limited Memorandum of Counsel of the Environment Court 23 April 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 Nichols Property Group and others - Notice of withdrawal of appeal (43) 15 June 2022 [Natural hazards |
Commercial and mixed use zones, Natural hazards
| Otago Regional Council Woolworths New Zealand Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Otago Regional Council ENV-2018-CHC-290 - Otago Regional Council Consent Memorandum Otago Regional Council (63) 15 October 2019 Consent memorandum Otago Regional Council (98) 15 October 2019 Otago Regional Council (140) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Heritage] 5 March 2020 Consent order for Otago Regional Council regarding dust control (63) 21 May 2020 Otago Regional Council (124,134) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Natural Hazards] 29 May 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding consent memo for ORC (98) 19 May 2020 Otago Regional Council (61) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Rural Provisions] 29 September 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Residential Strategic Bundle 4 December 2020 Consent order - Residential Strategic Bundle 18 December 2020 Otago Regional Council (65) Consent order issued by Environment Court 5 August 2021 Otago Regional Council (138) - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal [Natural Hazards Rules] 27 May 2022 Otago Regional Council (94) - Determination of Environment Court 21 August 2024 |
Earthworks (resolved), Heritage (withdrawn), Natural hazards, Public health and safety
| Balmoral Developments Outram Limited BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Gordon Road Spillway Residents Group Heritage New Zealand (withdrawn) Liquigas Limited (withdrawn) Ministry of Health (withdrawn) Oceana Gold Port Otago Limited University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
Phil Cunningham
ENV-2018-CHC-264 - Phil Cunningham
Phil Cunningham (109) Consent order issued by Environment Court 10 December 2021 |
Residential Zones
|
Otago Regional Council
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Port Otago Limited ENV-2018-CHC-245 - Port Otago Limited Port Otago Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (18, 20) 14 June 2022 [Port Provisions] Careys Bay Association Incorporated & Port Otago Limited (23, 25, 27, 34, 35) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Port Bundle] 04 August 2022 |
Port Zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Port Otago Limited - Harbourside Edge ENV-2018-CHC-246 - Port Otago Limited - Harbourside Edge Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - CMU Campus Bundle 23 April 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Otago Regional Council University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
Port Otago Limited - Port Activities ENV-2018-CHC-247 - Port Otago Limited - Port Activities Port Otago Limited - Consent order issued by Environment Court (369, 370) 20 September 2021 [Earthworks and Major Hazard Facilities Bundle] Port Otago Limited - Port Activities (368) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Earthworks, Natural environment, Public health and safety
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Liquigas Limited Royal Forest and Bird |
Appeal Resolved
|
Ravensdown Limited ENV-2018-CHC-237 - Ravensdown Limited Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (344) 31 May 2021 Ravensdown Limited (68, 72, 77, 79, 344) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Public health and safety
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Horticulture New Zealand Liquigas Limited Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Port Otago Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
RB and SO Chin ENV-2018-CHC-268 - RB and SO Chin RB and SO Chin (176) Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 October 2022 |
Urban land supply
|
Otago Regional Council
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Robert Duffy ENV-2018-CHC-253 - Robert Duffy Robert Duffy (192) - Consent Determination issued by the Environment Court 13 February 2024 |
Urban land supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Robert Francis Wyber ENV-2018-CHC-281 - Robert Francis Wyber DCC's reporting memorandum for Residential Strategic - Wyber 24 January 2020 Minute from Environment Court in response to memo for Residential Strategic Wyber 28 January 2020 Memorandum of Counsel for DCC regarding PCT and Wyber appeal 7 February 2020 Minute from Environment Court regarding PCT and Wyber case management 19 February 2020 Minute from Environment Court regarding Wyber and PCT case management 4 March 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Rural and Rural Residential consent memo 19 May 2020 Reporting memorandum for Robert Francis Wyber 10 July 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Wyber and PCT 15 July 2020 Memorandum of Counsel for DCC regarding PCT and Wyber 22 July 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court 4 December 2020 – Residential Strategic Bundle Robert Francis Wyber - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (212) 19 January 2021 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle 30 April 2021 Robert Francis Wyber (376) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 August 2021 [Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle] |
Rural residential zones, Urban land supply
| Anthony Reid and Hilary Evans BA Building Limited Balmoral Developments Outram Limited Ben Ponne Blueskin Bay Holdings Limited Daisy Link Garden Centres Limited Gladstone Family Trust Grant Maxwell Motion James Lin Limited Janefields Re-zone Group Phil Cunningham Radio New Zealand Limited - withdrawn RB and SO Chin Robert Charles Duffy Saddle Hill Group The Jensen Trust The Preservation Coalition Trust William John Morrison Yvonne Cummings |
Appeal Resolved
|
Roger Keith Miller ENV-2018-CHC-236 - Roger Keith Miller (part 1) ENV-2018-CHC-236 - Roger Keith Miller (part 2) Roger Keith Miller (49) Consent order issued by Environment Court 10 June 2022 |
Residential zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated ENV-2018-CHC-287 - Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated (part 264, 277, 279, 284, part 286, 287, 288, 289, 290, 291, 295, 296, 297, 299) Consent order issued by Environment Court [Biodiversity and Rail Bundle] 7 October 2022 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated (part 264, part 286, 281, 282) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 5 May 2023 |
Natural environment
| Aurora Energy Limited Director General of Conservation Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Robert Van Turnhout Saddle Views Estate Limited - withdrawn The Preservation Coalition Trust -withdrawn Transpower New Zealand Limited Tussock Top Farm Limited - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
Russell V Lund and H C Trustees Limited ENV-2018-CHC-221 - Russell V Lund and H C Trustees Limited Russell V Lund and H C Trustees Limited (11) - Decision of Environment Court 31 August 2023 |
Industrial zones
| Paula and Tim Cotter |
Appeal Resolved
|
Saddle Views Estate Limited ENV-2018-CHC-283 - Saddle Views Estate Limited Saddle Views Estate Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (326, 327, 388) 13 October 2020 Saddle Views Estate Limited (384, 386, 323, 324, 318, 319, 331, 332, 333, 334, 335, 320, 362, 330, 338, 336, 360) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] Saddle Views Estate Limited (325, 321, 337) Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal 22 April 2022 |
Natural environment, Natural hazards, Quarries and mining activities (cross plan hearing topic), Transportation
| Director General of Conservation Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Port Otago Limited Royal Forest and Bird University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
Silverpeaks Station Limited ENV-2018-CHC-272 - Silverpeaks Station Limited Silverpeaks Station Limited (250) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 27 May 2022 [Landscape] |
Natural environment
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
Stephen Gregory Johnston - 33 Otakou Golf Course Road ENV-2018-CHC-295 - Stephen Gregory Johnston - 33 Otakou Golf Course Road Stephen Gregory Johnston (364) - Consent Order issued by Environment Court 18 April 2023 |
Rural residential zones
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Stephen Gregory Johnston - Karitane ENV-2018-CHC-296 - Stephen Gregory Johnston - Karitane Stephen Gregory Johnston (Karitane) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 June 2025 |
Urban land supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
Stephen Gregory Johnston - Patmos Ave ENV-2018-CHC-297 - Stephen Gregory Johnston - Patmos Ave Stephen Gregory Johnston - Patmos Ave (119) Consent order issued by Environment Court 29 September 2022 |
Urban land supply
| Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
The Estate of Barry Smaill ENV-2018-CHC-280 - Barry Smaill ENV-2018-CHC-280 Memorandum of Counsel - Smaill ENV-2018-CHC-280 Reporting Memorandum of Counsel - Smaill 27.9.19 ENV-2018-CHC-280 - email response from Environment Court 30.9.19 Env-2018-CHC-280 Reporting Memorandum of Counsel - Smaill 29 November 2019 Consent Memorandum Barry Smaill 28 February 2020 Barry Smaill - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (209,210) 5 March 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Barry Smaill consent memo 19 May 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court 4 December 2020 – Residential Strategic Bundle Consent order - Barry Smaill 17 December 2020 The Estate of Barry Smaill - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (211) 21 September 2022 [Residential] |
Residential Zones
| |
Appeal Resolved
|
The Jensen Trust ENV-2018-CHC-275 - The Jensen Trust The Jensen Trust (180) Consent order issued by Environment Court 5 November 2021 |
Urban land supply
| Michel de Lange Otago Regional Council |
Appeal Resolved
|
The Preservation Coalition Trust (PCT) ENV-2018-CHC-285 - The Preservation Coalition Trust (PCT) PCT - replacement 12 January 2019 PCT - amended 19 February 2019 PCT Environment Court issues 16.4.19 PCT Environment Court issues - Map PCT - Application for directions 17 October 2019 Minute of Environment Court regarding PCT 22 October 2019 PCT case management memo by Counsel for DCC 25 October 2019 PCT memo to Environment Court 29 October 2019 PCT waiver application 29 October 2019 PCT case management memo by Counsel for DCC 29 October 2019 PCT memorandum of Counsel for extension of time 1 November 2019 Minute of Environment Court regarding PCT timetable 5 November 2019 PCT notice from DCC in response to waiver 6 November 2019 Affidavit of Michael John Bathgate for DCC, PCT 11 November 2019 PCT record of telephone conference 14 November 2019 PCT agreed bundle of documents related to scope 70 (2) 15 November 2019 PCT agreed bundle of documents related to scope 71 (2) 15 November 2019 PCT report from Counsel for DCC 2 December 2019 University of Otago's memorandum to the Court regarding PCT conferencing 2 December 2019 Affidavit of Craig Werner for PCT 3 December 2019 Record of teleconference between DCC and PCT 6.12.19 PCT memo in response to Environment Court minute dated 6 December 2019 Notice of Assisted Dispute Resolution 9 December 2019 Legal submission regarding PCT appeal point 70b 18 December 2019 Legal submission regarding PCT appeal point 71 18 December 2019 DCC's Legal Counsel's Application for Directions following ADR 20 December 2019 PCT response ADR 20 January 2020 Minute of Environment Court in response to application for directions 21 January 2020 PCT - Notice of Expert Conference - Landscape 24 January 2020 DCC's Memorandum of Counsel regarding PCT, 24 January 2020 PCT Legal Counsel's memo in reply to Court minute of 21 January 2020, 24 January 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding PCT case management 28 January 2020 PCT - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (86) 29 January 2020 PCT memo Identifying relief sought for Topic C 3 February 2020 Memorandum of Counsel for DCC regarding PCT and Wyber appeal 7 February 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding PCT and Wyber case management 19 February 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Motion, Morrison and PCT 4 March 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Wyber and PCT 4 March 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding hearing date (70b, 71) 11 March 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Motion, Morrison and PCT 19 March 2020 Record of teleconference between PCT and DCC 24 March 2020 Memo - chronology of appeal (appeal point 71) 3 April 2020 Memorandum from DCC in relation to landscape conferencing 1 May 2020 Minute of Environment Court in response to landscape conferencing memo 6 May 2020 PCT - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (71) 8 May 2020 Memorandum from DCC in response to above Environment Court minute (overlaps) 15 May 2020 PCT amended appeal 18 May 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Rural and Rural Residential consent memo 19 May 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding the Landscape Architect Joint Witness Statement 1 April 2020 Updated Joint Witness Statement 3 June 2020 Position Statement for the DCC regarding the Joint Witness Statement 5 June 2020 Memorandum of Counsel regarding the Joint Witness Statement for PCT 3 July 2020 PCT reply memorandum on scope 6 July 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding PCT 14 July 2020 Memorandum of Counsel for DCC regarding PCT and Wyber 22 July 2020 Memo from PCT regarding consequential relief 23 July 2020 PCT 3rd amended appeal 18 August 2020 PCT Waiver Application 31 August 2020 PCT 4th amended notice of appeal 21 September 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court - Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle 30 April 2021 PCT (90, 91) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 13 August 2021 [Rural / Rural Residential Strategic Bundle] PCT - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal point 82 regarding the SNL that overlays the property at 457 Highcliff road 24 September 2021 PCT (75, 82, part 70, 341) and Bruce Wayne Taylor (13) - Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court Landscape Bundle 17 November 2021 PCT (75, 82, part 70, 341) and Bruce Wayne Taylor (13) Consent order issued by Environment Court 24 November 2021 PCT - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (part 70, 96) 18 February 2022 PCT - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal on all unresolved matters (part 93) 7 March 2022 |
Natural environment, Rural residential zones, Rural zones, Urban land supply
| Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated - withdrawn Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou - Notice of Kati Huirapa Runaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Runanga o Otakou withdrawing s274 interest 18 June 2020
Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Save The Otago Peninsula (STOP) University of Otago - Memo of partial withdrawal of University of Otago s274 interest
- Memo of partial withdrawal of University of Otago s274 interest 18 March 2020
|
Appeal Resolved
|
Transpower New Zealand Limited ENV-2018-CHC-249 - Transpower New Zealand Limited Memorandum of Counsel - Residential Strategic Bundle 4 December 2020 Transpower New Zealand Limited - Consent order - Residential Strategic Bundle 18 December 2020 Transpower New Zealand Limited - Consent order issued by Environment Court (97) 20 September 2021 [Earthworks and Major Hazard Facilities Bundle] Transpower New Zealand Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (122, 384) 6 December 2021 Transpower New Zealand Limited (118, 390, 391, 392, 393, 145, 146, 152, 103, 114, 135, 141) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] Transpower New Zealand Limited (144) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Network utilities, Plan overview and structure, Public health and safety
| Aurora Energy Limited Federated Farmers of New Zealand Incorporated Horticulture New Zealand Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Liquigas Limited Royal Forest and Bird Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu University of Otago |
Appeal Resolved
|
Tussock Top Farms Limited ENV-2018-CHC-282 - Tussock Top Farms Limited Tussock Top Farms Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (304, 305, 389) and s274 interest 13 October 2020 Tussock Top Farms Limited (301, 302, 309, 306, 307, 308, 315, 317, 311, 312, 313, 314, 294, 292, 293, 310, 385, 387) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 16 February 2022 [Network Utilities and Mining Bundle] Tussock Top Farms Limited - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (303, 298, 316) 23 February 2022 |
Natural environment, Natural hazards, Quarries and mining activities (cross plan hearing topic), Transportation
| Director General of Conservation Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki and Te Rūnanga o Ōtākou Oceana Gold Otago Regional Council Plaman Resources Limited - withdrawn Port Otago Limited Royal Forest and Bird University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved
|
University of Otago ENV-2018-CHC-270 - University of Otago Memorandum of Counsel regarding Variation 1 17 December 2019 University of Otago - Partial Withdrawal of Appeal (206) and s274 notices 23 April 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Woolworths and University of Otago 29 June 2020 Memorandum of Counsel regarding Woolworths and University of Otago 3 July 2020 University of Otago - Partial withdrawal of appeal (246) and s274 notices 21 July 2020 University of Otago - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (191, 205) 8 September 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court 23 April 2021 Consent Order - University of Otago (215,236) 10 June 2021 Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 University of Otago (241) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 28 April 2022 [Scheduled trees] University of Otago - Notice of partial withdrawal of appeal (224) 15 June 2022 [Heritage] University of Otago (part 213) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 11 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] University of Otago (part 213) - Consent order issued by Environment Court 14 August 2023 [Hazardous Substances Bundle] |
Earthworks (resolved), Heritage (withdrawn), Natural hazards, Public health and safety
| Bindon Holdings Limited Heritage New Zealand Liquigas Limited Otago Regional Council - withdrawn Port Otago Limited |
Appeal Resolved
|
Willowridge Developments Limited ENV-2018-CHC-219 - Willowridge Developments Limited Willowridge Development Limited (17) Consent order issued by Environment Court 2 December 2021 |
Urban land supply
| Anthony Haereroa Parata - Notice of Anthony Parata withdrawing Section 274 Interest 18 December 2020
Blueskin Bay Watch Society Incorporated Gerald Fitzgerald Kāti Huirapa Rūnaka Ki Puketeraki Lee Paterson Otago Regional Council Southern Clams Limited Waitati Beach Reserve Society Incorporated |
Appeal Resolved
|
Woolworths New Zealand Limited ENV-2018-CHC-255 - Woolworths New Zealand Limited Memorandum of Counsel regarding Variation 1 17 December 2019 Memorandum from Liquigas Limited withdrawing s274 interest 1 May 2020 Memorandum from University of Otago withdrawing s274 interest 8 May 2020 Joint Memorandum of Counsel between Woolworths and DCC 11 June 2020 Minute of Environment Court regarding Woolworths and University of Otago 29 June 2020 Memorandum of Counsel regarding Woolworths and University of Otago 3 July 2020 Memorandum of Counsel to the Environment Court 28 April 2021 - Commercial and mixed use zones/Campus Bundle Consent Order - CMU / Campus Bundle 11 June 2021 |
Commercial and mixed use zones
| BP Oil New Zealand Limited and Others Foodstuffs South Island Properties Limited Liquigas Limited - withdrawn University of Otago - withdrawn |
Appeal Resolved |
